Antireflux
operations such as the Nissen
fundoplication and its
modifications e.g. Toupet, Rosetti
and Dor fundoplication, the Hill
operation, the Belsey Mark IV and
the Collis operations to cure
reflux and have been practiced by
open surgery with incisions
through the abdomen (Nissen and
its modifications) or through the
Chest (Belsey) since the 1950’s.
Since
1987 when Phillip Mouret performed
the first cholecystectomy laparoscopically, i.e. with small
incisions rather than one large
incision. Many operations have been
perfected by the laparoscopic
approach. Among the most
popular are the Nissen
fundoplication and its
modifications.
Nissen, a Swiss surgeon, did his
first fundoplication for reflux disease in the
fifties. Nineteen years earlier, he had performed the
same operation for cancer of the
esophagus in Turkey before World
War II. He was not satisfied with
the anastomosis between the
esophagus and the stomach so he
wrapped the suture line with the
stomach. He lost track of the
patient and moved back to
Switzerland at the outbreak of the
war. Nineteen years later, the
nephew of the patient went to him
in Switzerland. Nissen asked the nephew if his
aunt was suffering from severe
heartburn and reflux since he had
removed the valve or LES with the
cancer. When he found out that she
had no reflux he started using
that method (wrapping the stomach
around the lower esophagus) for
reflux disease or GERDS and hiatal
hernia. This operation proved to
be very successful giving over 90%
relief ten years after the
surgery.
Laparoscopic
or Minimally Invasive
fundoplications are essentially
identical to the open operations
and have yielded comparable
results to the open cases
approaching the 10 years. There is
no reason to believe that the two
approaches should not have similar
long-term results. The major
advantage laparoscopic surgery has
over the open surgery is that now
we can address the less than
satisfactory results earlier since
the pain and morbidity is much
less than with the open approach. We
are now accumulating a lot of
experience reoperating patients
who have previously had open or
laparoscopic surgery. To redo a
laparoscopic surgery is somewhat
easier because fewer adhesions
exist than after open surgery.
In
the Nissen fundoplication the
stomach is wrapped around the
lower esophagus similar to the way
a mother hugs her child.